P3: Reflection – E.W.

P3 was both such a joy and a challenge because it asked us to design with the approach that nothing truly exists in isolation. Each element of our game is situated in a specific, shared context in which they mutually influence one another. I remember many times during our team meetings when one of us wanted to change one element (for example, selling bundles of ingredients in the market), which meant a related mechanic had to change (e.g., adjusting the prices), which then forced yet another change (e.g., reducing the market size). Much of our game iteration saw many chain reactions because of all the relationships each element had with other elements or mechanics. 

The current look of our market in the game!

I also do not think that system relationships are necessarily transactional, even though one could argue that the relationships we modeled in our P3 game were since we were essentially representing small business management. I am reminded of something Olu said during our write-up, that the random events we put into our game are a key feature because they influence the budgeting mechanics that are players’ points of interaction with our represented system. His words help me reframe restaurant management as an “ecosystem” where patterns occur but are constantly in flux because elements are situated within an every-changing context (which the “ecology” part emphasizes for the definition of an “ecosystem”). 

For P3, each gameplay experience was different due to iteration but also, in large part, because of the different players we had (our context). A game designer can theoretically map out all the effects that one lever or element has on another, leading to a multitude of game endings. But even with this map, the game designer can never truly predict what the actual gameplay experience will be because of the context that gameplay occurs in that is ultimately shaped by the players. The ways that the patterns in a game’s ecosystem can occur result from different combinations of players, prior player experience with this game, player preferences for games, players’ strategies, and the prior knowledge players have about the topic represented. 

The importance of context for a systems game reminds me of my Muwekma Native Plant garden class. In that class, we constantly talk about how we are not separate from the garden we are growing, but an active member of it alongside other actors (e.g., plants, animals, the river, even the history of the land). We are part of the garden’s ecosystem, and our interactions with it are informed by the identities, experiences, and values we each bring. Similarly, I think systems games offer us the opportunity to reevaluate and better understand the world as made up of living ecosystems that we are all actors within. This P3 experience makes me reflect on our agency as players in a game and people in nature-made and man-made systems, for it is through our choices that patterns both occur and can change.

About the author

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.