Read & Play: The Rhetoric of Video Games – snoopy

Read:

  • Animal crossing teaches about debt!
    • Get more stuff, need more space. Get more space, need more stuff. All this has a cost, and no matter what you get into debt.
    • You see Tom Nook get richer because of this.
    • Very condensed capitalism. You work and buy, and you see Tom Nook get richer. Tom Nook always gets richer. You see where the flow of money goes.
  • “Video games are not just stages that facilitate cultural, social, or political practices; they are also media where cultural values themselves can be represented—for critique, satire, education, or commentary. When understood in this way, we can learn to read games as deliberate expressions of particular perspectives. In other words, video games make claims about the world, which players can understand, evaluate, and deliberate. Game developers can learn to create games that make deliberate expressions about the world”.
    • Big quote… This helps to set up the idea of procedural rhetoric later.

Play:

  • People often view playthings (games) as not legitimate learning venue
    • Play and learning often segregated in schools
    • Video games often indeed subscribe to being “unproductive usages of time”
  • “Play is the free space of movement within a more rigid structure.” – Katie Salen and Eric Zimmerman
    • We see similar stuff in non-games, of movement being renegotiated in rules (like when writing book with certain letters only, in a haiku, etc.).
    • Video games allow this movement within rules more easily. Greater possibility space.

Procedurality:

  • Procedurality, participation, spatiality, encyclopedic scope
  • Procedurality is the ability to define and execute a series of rules
    • Video games teach subject-centered literacy, but also about the precoedurality itself. Computers can limit the latter.
    • This again is an argument to support the idea of procedural rhetoric.

Rhetoric:

  • Claims, arguments about cultural, social, material aspects of human experience, is rhetoric.
    • Can be deliberate or inadvertent
    • In contemporary rhetoric, persuasion is less important – clarity and communication more important.
  • Rhetoric can be visual – photographs, illustrations, etc.
  • Helps to understand our complex systems
  • Digital rhetoric? (email, websites, message boards, blogs).
    • Honestly I don’t buy this, and argue this is no different than the above rhetorical methods. Sure we can group it by medium, but I don’t like that. That’s like saying magazine written rhetoric is different than book written rhetoric.

Procedural Rhetoric:

  • Authoring arguments through processes
    • Subdomain of procedural authorship? i.e., argument made from construction of rules of behavior, not from words or images
  • Argues distinct from verbal, written, visual rhetoric as affords new claims on understanding how things work, i.e., the process
  • Can challenge models
    • McDonalds game (anti-advertisement game). The processes used in the game to succeed highlight corruption with global fast food. The game is procedural rhetoric about necessity of corruption for this sort of process (player must lobby, do evil, etc. to continue to grow).

Ways to Use Procedural Rhetoric:

  • Expose and explain hidden ways of thinking that drive social, political, cultural behavior? (ideology)
    • Army game including rules of engagement, separating from other FPS games, to show military is different? Very honor and rules based, correlation of honor with performance
  • Game does good job showing values and practice, but has risk: can bring criticism
    • Also what if not fun?

Ways to Use Procedural Rhetoric: Making and Unpacking an Argument

  • Can also be used to make explicit claims about the way a system works (like McDonalds game)
    • “Take Back Illinois” breaks down dry and abstract political topics by making each a sub-focus/game within the game, and then connecting them with voting/citizen engagement.
      • Each attempted to be compressed into smallest possible, simple ruleset
      • To play game successfully, player must acknowledge game positions on issues (i.e., impossible to win medical malpractice reform game without reducing maximum noneconomic damages for malpractice suits)
    • Player isn’t forced to make decision, but forced to understand

Learning from Procedural Rhetoric:

  • When we play, we explore a possibility of rules. We can learn and evaluate the game’s meaning through this
  • Video games can help break down cultural or social practices through sets of processes. We can teach, challenge, or support video games
  • Video games need to be used in settings to teach this, and need to be respected as modes that can teach

 

Play:

Funnily enough, these Read and Play assignments are helping me discover just how many games I own, but have not yet gotten around to playing. Remembering the excited reviews when it came out, I decided to play This War of Mine. Developed and published by 11 Bit Studios, This War of Mine is a strategy game centered around guiding a group of surviving civilians during a civil war. Available on most modern gaming platforms (Windows, Mac, iOS, PlayStation, Xbox, Switch, etc.), this narrative-rich game seems to target young adults with its more complicated/intense themes, i.e. the survival and suffering among innocent populations in war-torn areas.

I played two hours of the game, or roughly 7 in-game day/night cycles (the playthrough can range between 20-50 days before a “ceasefire” is reached). During gameplay, the player must manage the daily needs of a group of survivors during civil war, including the necessity for food, water, security (having someone on watch), morale, etc. The player’s characters can leave during the nighttime to go on dangerous missions for supplies (or stay to get needed sleep and recovery from wounds and illness), and must manage their daytime activities (cooking, crafting, etc.) well in the limited amount of time given.

One of the player characters on a looting mission.

As a survival/strategy game, it is particularly well-suited to interactively demonstrating the difficult moral concept: the depth of struggle and suffering to a civilian populace in war. While something as rhetorically nuanced might seem at first an option to be broached by something more narratively driven, incorporating the systems necessary to show basic human needs, and tasking the player with managing these, makes the experience more visceral. As was described in Ian Bogost’s “The Rhetoric of Video Games,” a game can introduce and break down complex difficult human experiences – especially those resulting from the interaction of human systems – through the incorporation of procedural rhetoric. This War of Mine does this masterfully by submersing the player in this complex system of rules and needs (i.e., those dictated by the player being in a war-torn city), and forcing the player to understand its nuances by “playing”. The player can then challenge and critique this system, hopefully bringing them to ponder the real-world analogy.

That isn’t to say the game doesn’t also heavily employ narrative techniques to personify each gloomy moment. In fact, the little lore elements built into exploration, resource management, and day-to-day survival were some of my favorite factors in the game that communicated the message. While procedural rhetoric is a powerful tool in its own – simple, traditional rhetorical techniques (i.e., written, verbal, visual) help make it feel that much more human.

One of the journal entries, alongside the hideout inventory.

For example, the player’s characters keep a little journal to document their thoughts, giving the player additional information into what needs still need to be met. The survivors can build a radio to tune into messages that can give them more information on the world around them. The simple cold, grey gloominess around speaks as much about the temperature as the thermometer indicator built into the player’s screen. The player must balance learning about the world around them with simply surviving in it – building an interactive and deeply personal experience.

Overall, the game does a good job on broaching the difficult concept that is the effect of war on non-combatants. While it could have done so in a more serious and less game-ified, strategic manner, its expansion of the topic into the realm of “play” in fact opens the concept up to a wider audience and lets its nuances be broached in new ways (i.e., seeing for yourself that you simply cannot manage getting enough food in the winter, rather than being told that). What the game sacrifices in truthful recollection of the horrors of war, and the magnitudes of suffering thereof, it makes up in being the “first step”, getting a wider audience to think about the concept in a wider way. From there, interested parties can take the more frightful leap into the topic, and begin to combat the great plague that is war.

About the author

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.