Read & Play: The Rhetoric of Video Games – Sabrina

Notes on The Rhetoric of Video Games can be found here.

For this Read & Play, I played Spent and and It’s Just a Burning Memory.

Spent

Spent is a single player game about making it through the month on a tight budget, created by the Urban Ministries of Durham and McKinney. It is available on the web (link to play here: https://playspent.org/html/) and, while no explicit target audience is listed, the topics seem targeted towards teenagers / adults who may not understand why financial support is important or necessary. In the game, you play as an unemployed American who lost their house and is down to their last $1000. You must make it through a month on your savings, encountering various situations which impact your budget in different ways. I played through the entire game in about half an hour.

Spent tries to convey the message that simply surviving on a tight budget is very difficult, even if you make “all the right choices.” While not explicitly stated, it also emphasizes how the Urban Ministries of Durham’s work is therefore important and a necessary factor in survival for many players.

Spent would most likely be in the category of a simulation game, as the player is given various scenarios that they would likely encounter in the real world. This choice is core to communicating their message because it forces the player to put themselves in the shoes of the type of person game tries to create empathy for.

The core mechanics also strongly demonstrate the use of procedure rhetoric, as the experience living on a tight budget is encapsulated into a core set of rules, which the player explores the impact of through playing the game.

Choices you make, such as which job you’ll choose, impact your remaining savings. The hidden costs (uniform, taxes) are made explicit and emphasized.

This procedure rhetoric is used to make and unpack an argument. The game opens as a challenge: do you think you can really survive off of just $1000?

The opening premise of the game: playing through is a challenge.

Every choice the player is confronted with is viewed in the context of the savings they have left. Some choices are more direct than others: choosing a job will gain you a certain amount of money. However, many choices have a twist or hidden cost, such as needing to pay for the uniform of your job or losing a certain amount of money to taxes. Additionally, other choices put your savings directly at the cost of your happiness, such a choosing to go to a free concert at the cost of spending extra money on a babysitter.

A free concert isn’t so free if you have to pay for a babysitter…

The game is difficult on purpose. Forcing players to think through difficult choices and being able to just scrape by at the sacrifice of some of their happiness illustrates the developer’s argument: it’s much harder than you might think to get by.

Overall, the choices are effective. Playing through made me face many difficult decisions and I experienced tension and uncertainty of choosing between things like comfort, standing up for yourself, and ultimately, money. Because of how accurate and direct each of the choices were, Spent avoided suffering from ludonarrative dissonance: every choice would provide you some benefit to your life at the cost of having to spend more money.

My main criticism would be the lack of narrative weight. Every day presented a new scenario and there was not much of a through-line between each, aside from large choices like your job. I think having to sit with the consequences of each decision for a little longer would help build more empathy for the character you play in the story.

It’s Just a Burning Memory

I also played It’s Just a Burning Memory (henceforth referred to as Burning Memory), a single-player narrative game created in CS377G by Tianze and published on the web (link to play here: https://shancha.rathat.top/). The game also does not have a specified target audience, but based on the content, it appears to be suitable for teenagers and above. I played through the entire game in a little under an hour.

In Burning Memory, you play as a researcher digitally exploring the memories of a patient presented as a filesystem. This patient, you learn, is a former soldier named Gregor and through exploring these memories, you piece together what happened in his life and how he got to be where he is today.

Burning Memory attempts to convey how memory is fragile, yet fundamental to the way we are as people, while creating empathy for those with Alzheimers. I found it to be extremely effective in its goals, utilizing a touching narrative, engaging game mechanics, and a representation of memory like computer files.

When I started this game, I did not think it was going to make me cry. But thirty minutes later, I was quietly sobbing in the middle of a café, part of which was due to its choice of genre. Burning Memory is initially presented as a puzzle or mystery. Given only fragments of Gregor’s memory, the player must piece together what is happening as well as search for key words that allow you to discover more memories. By presenting this open question initially, the game builds interest and creates fun through discovery. Instead of having to immediately understand the characters, I was motivated to continue playing in order to figure out what is going on.

The player is thrust into exploring Gregor’s memories with no context. Who is Gregor and what is the world they are exploring like?

Spent and Burning Memory take opposite approaches to conveying their message. While Spent focuses on modeling a system, Burning Memory creates a story. By spending time trying to figure out what was happening in the story, I inevitably became attached to the characters. Thus, although the procedures were less involved, they had far more emotional impact. Specifically, Burning Memory hones in on the importance of memory when you learn Gregor suffers from an inserted memory which has caused deterioration of his mental capacity. The player is then given the choice to remove that deleted memory in hopes of saving him, but at the cost of removing themselves from Gregor’s life.

Do you choose to delete yourself?

The procedural rhetoric illustrates the fragile nature of memory and the confusion that arises from mental illnesses like Alzheimers. However, the narrative carries the emotional connection and empathy for the characters, which makes the message more understood. This difference is where Burning Memory shines in comparison to Spent. I held a much deeper understanding of Burning Memory‘s message because I cared about the character, while Spent largely demonstrated its difficulty on an informational level. Burning Memory tied together these strategies in a way that avoids ludonarrative dissonance: the choices your character makes directly aid the message, rather than contradict it.

Takeaways

Playing both of these games helped me gain a better understanding of my own taste and the type of game I find effective. I really loved the choices made in Burning Memory, such as the non-linear storyline, the gripping nature of utilizing mystery, and the emotional impact garnered through reading memories and making a few key choices. Spent is not the type of game I typically enjoy, but it is effective: forcing players to make difficult choices effectively conveys a message, especially if it is about a system. I want to utilize both in my game: potentially using memories or a more linear storyline to create an emotional journey while also giving players non-trivial choices to force them to consider their actions.

About the author

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.