Critical Play: Puzzles – Karina Li

Monument Valley, a mobile puzzle game developed by Ustwo games for iOS, Android, console, and PC, is designed for players who enjoy visually-driven spatial reasoning and calm, contemplative play. The game centers around guiding a silent princess named Ida through a series of impossible structures, using optical illusions and architecture that can be rotated and shifted to create paths forward. Players interact with the environment by rotating towers, sliding platforms, and aligning disjointed shapes to reveal solutions. The world itself is a puzzle. Through its perspective-based mechanics, strong environmental design, and elegant pacing, Monument Valley creates a uniquely meditative puzzle experience that rewards experimentation and visual intuition.

Figure 1: Minimal Onboarding
Figure 2: Checkpoints throughout the level

 

 

 

These core mechanics support what Bob Bates describes as “information puzzles” and “machinery puzzles.” These are challenges that rely on players discovering how the environment works through observation and experimentation rather than direct instruction. Monument Valley does a great job onboarding new users without needing excessive tutorials (Figure 1). The level design is tight, with minimal UI and clear visual feedback, making it a strong model for intuitive puzzle teaching. Each level also includes clear checkpoints (black square tiles) that serve as visual anchors, and signal the player’s objective without explicit cues (Figure 2).

Figure 3: Before rotating
Figure 4: After rotating

Using the MDA framework, the mechanics include interactive elements like levers, sliders, and perspective-altering platforms. The dynamics emerge as players explore how these mechanics behave over time. For example, players realize that a disconnected path can be completed by visually aligning its ends from a rotated platform that was originally at a lower height (Figure 3, Figure 4). The aesthetic outcome is a feeling of quiet discovery.

Sound design further reinforces this aesthetic. Each action, rotating, tapping, completing a level, is paired with soft musical tones and ambient feedback. This subtle audio layer provides satisfying cues that support experimentation and help guide players without explicitly directing them. As Scott Kim explains, good puzzles are “fun and have a right answer. Monument Valley accomplishes this, creating joy in simply moving through the space and manipulating its architecture.

Unlike many traditional puzzle games, Monument Valley avoids punishing the player. There are no fail states, time limits, or scoring systems. This supports a low-stress, low-risk dynamic that encourages exploratory play. The game keeps players engaged by slowly layering complexity, but never overwhelming them. It invites casual players in while still offering enough structure to reward focus and patience.

One area where Monument Valley could improve is replayability. Most puzzles have a single intended solution, which makes repeat playthroughs feel linear and predictable. Once you complete the level, there is little incentive to come back to it. Introducing alternative solutions, such as allowing multiple paths to success, would give the puzzles more depth and creative flexibility. For example, a level could be solvable by rotating a tower clockwise or counterclockwise, each path revealing different environmental details or shortcuts. This small change would encourage experimentation and reward players who think outside the intended route, all without disrupting the game’s minimalist design philosophy.

Monument Valley is praised for its minimalist, almost universal design. But there are still assumptions built into the game. Most of the puzzles rely on spatial reasoning and familiarity with isometric visuals. Players who don’t naturally “read” 3D space, whether due to visual impairments or different educational backgrounds, may find the game less intuitive. It also assumes access to a device with a touch interface and the patience to experiment with it. While it avoids language barriers by using symbols and sound, it still leans heavily on modernist design influences, which may not resonate with all players.

To make the game more accessible, the designers could add an optional guided visual mode that previews how the level will change before and after an interaction, such as a hint system that lightly animates the expected outcome of a move. This would support players who struggle with abstract spatial prediction by offering clearer cause-and-effect feedback. The designers could also include adjustable contrast modes or simplified visual decorations for those with visual impairments. This way, players can still access the core experiences without compromising the primary puzzle design and its design aesthetic. 

Monument Valley shows that puzzles don’t need to be hard to be meaningful. By focusing on shifting perspective, both visually and emotionally, it creates a unique experience that feels thoughtful and complete. The game teaches through play, supports a wide range of players, and ties its mechanics directly to its tone and story.

About the author

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.