Before embarking on the P3 systems game, I had a vague understanding of systems thinking. I imagined it as a complex web of interconnected elements, but I hadn’t fully grasped its potential for game design. I anticipated a technical challenge, but I was also excited to explore the creative possibilities of a systemic approach.
As we delved into the project, I was surprised by the depth and nuance of the systems we were designing. Our game, inspired by the concept of enshittification, aimed to model the gradual degradation of an online platform. We focused on key factors like user engagement, revenue, and reputation, and how they interacted with each other.
The most interesting part of the process was balancing simplicity and complexity. We wanted to create a game that was accessible to a wide audience, but we also wanted to capture the intricate dynamics of a real-world system. We experimented with different mechanics, such as adjusting ad frequency, personalizing content, and investing in platform upgrades. Each decision had a ripple effect, influencing multiple variables and shaping the overall trajectory of the platform.
One of the most significant challenges we encountered was modeling the complex mathematical formulas that underpin the system. The reality of platform degradation is a multifaceted phenomenon influenced by a myriad of factors, making it difficult to distill into a single, definitive model. We grappled with the tension between simplicity and accuracy. A overly simplistic model could fail to capture the nuances of the system, while a highly complex model could be difficult to implement and understand. The final version that we experimented with, though it is not perfect, we tried our best to model how we perceive as enshittification.
Meanwhile, watching others play the game was equally fascinating. It was enlightening to see how different players approached the same challenges. Some focused on short-term gains, while others prioritized long-term sustainability. Some were risk-takers, while others played it safe. These diverse strategies highlighted the inherent unpredictability of complex systems.
Through this experience, I gained a deeper appreciation for the power of systems thinking. I learned that even seemingly simple systems can exhibit complex and emergent behavior. I also realized the importance of playtesting and iterative design. By observing how players interacted with the game, we were able to identify areas for improvement and refine the mechanics.
Looking forward, I believe that systems thinking can be applied to a wide range of creative endeavors. By understanding the underlying structures and relationships between elements, we can create more engaging and meaningful experiences. Whether it’s designing a game, writing a story, or solving a real-world problem, a systems perspective can provide valuable insights and innovative solutions.
