Critical Play: Competitive Analysis – Ryan Kang

I playtested Cards Against Humanity, a popular party game where players complete statements with humorous or “spicy” words from their cards. It’s super fun for its simplicity and how it makes everyone laugh with its ridiculous statements. Our team’s game taps into a similar vibe, where players become characters and have timed debates over silly topics, like Walter White arguing whether a taco is a sandwich. Here’s how our game and Cards Against Humanity stack up against each other.

Cards Against Humanity is really for adults who enjoy dark humor and hanging out with friends. It’s especially fun when you can throw in personal jokes. Our game targets a similar crowd—mostly adults who’ll get a kick out of crafting ridiculous arguments, ideally among friends.

The creators of Cards Against Humanity are Max Temkin, Ben Hantoot, and others who put together a game that’s all about quick setups and laughs. Our game follows in those footsteps, being easy to start and great for any social setting, making it perfect as a party game.

Our game spices things up by mixing role-playing, debate, and a bit of strategy into the gameplay. This not only makes the game more engaging but also gets players really involved and using different skills than they would just picking cards.

Here’s what sets our game apart:

  • Roles and Mechanics: Players in our game take on specific roles like Challenger, Challengee, and Judge, which switch up throughout the game. This adds a strategic layer that’s missing in Cards Against Humanity, where you’re mostly just picking cards.
  • Timed Debates: We’ve designed debates with time limits, pushing players to think fast and stay sharp, which is a big shift from the more laid-back card picking in Cards Against Humanity.
  • Character-Driven Arguments: Players argue from their character’s perspective, which means they have to weave their character’s traits into their arguments. This adds depth and a lot of fun to the gameplay, making it more immersive compared to the random card draws in Cards Against Humanity.

So, while both games share the goal of having a blast and laughing over the absurd, our game brings a fresh twist with more active participation and creativity.

About the author

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.